What If your Cat Outlives You?

Bookmark and Share

Deciding what will become of your pet(s) should you be incapacitated or die is a difficult decision. If you are a breeder with a fully cattery, you have a greater burden than the average pet owner when it comes to planning ahead. There are two primary legal mechanisms to provide for your pets: non-trust arrangements and trusts.

Non-Trust Arrangements
The simplest method of providing for your cat(s) is to designate — in writing — a caretaker to take custody if need arises, before or after your death. Name several backups in case your first choice is unable (or unwilling) to serve when the time comes. Provide a written “letter of instruction” with specific directions as to which cats are to be placed with which caretaker, and the exact care each cat should receive. Identify the cats as specifically as possible, and don’t forget to add the words “and any other cats I own at the time I die or am incapacitated.”

If you cannot identify an appropriate caregiver, designate someone with good judgment to select one. Provide a copy of the letter of instruction to each person affected, and place a copy with your important papers. If you have a power of attorney, make sure that person has a copy of the letter and has the authority to make expenditures on behalf of your cats while you are incapacitated and before a will is probated. You may want to incorporate your letter of instruction into your will. Although perhaps not fully enforceable, this may influence how your executor disposes of your cat(s) and your money.

The problem with merely designating a caretaker and leaving a letter of instruction is the lack of legal assurance your wishes will be followed. Leaving your estate to your cat(s) directly is not an option: Courts of any state will reject such a provision. The alternative to this quandary is to create a trust.

Creating a Trust
A trust is an arrangement whereby you place assets in the care of a trustee, who has a fiduciary duty to use those assets according to your wishes on behalf of the beneficiary (or beneficiaries) that you designate. You designate a caregiver for your cat(s) and, as described below, either the cat(s) or the caregiver may be your beneficiary. Include directions (similar to the letter of instruction) in the trust document, describing exactly what care the caregiver should provide for your dogs on a daily basis, right down to their breeding and showing careers, housing, food, medical needs, veterinarians, and which toys they prefer. Designating different people as caregiver and trustee ensures there are checks and balances in place (although a caregiver may be a co-trustee as well). Even though you have a trust, you can leave the cat(s) as property to someone in your will. Naming the caregiver as at least one of the future owners may help avoid future ownership disputes.

Types of Trusts

  • Pet Trusts: A pet trust is a specific arrangement, legally recognized in half the states, in which your pet is the beneficiary. As noted above, the trust document should specifically identify the beneficiary cat(s), using DNA, microchip numbers, call name, CFA name and number, photos, and so on.
  • Common law trusts:  In other states, a pet trust is not legally enforceable. Residents can designate only human beneficiaries, not pets. But even in one of these states, you can establish a “common law trust.” To make certain the common law trust is effective, (a) ensure the caregiver receives funds on a frequent basis (not all at once or only once a year), and (b) ensure funds are disbursed conditionally, i.e., in order to continue receiving funds, the caregiver must frequently check in with the trustee and demonstrate that proper care is being given to the cat(s). This provision helps ensure that the “checks and balances” will work properly. A common law trust set up this way is generally legally enforceable.

Choosing a trustee: For both types of trust, you must designate a trustee — someone you know and can rely on, or an attorney, or a bank, or one of the various organizations that are willing to serve as trustee for pet trusts—and also identify backups. You can also appoint co-trustees. A caretaker should be appointed co-trustee only if there is at least one independent trustee. Whoever you choose as trustees, talk to them now to ensure they agree to serve.

Choosing a caregiver. As with trustees, contact potential caregivers now about your plans. For a professional breeder, the caretaker almost certainly must be a “cat person,” willing to take your cat(s) into their home or cattery and continue your breeding and showing program. If your loved ones cannot do this, consider reputable fellow breeders. If a caretaker is not available for cats that will not be shown, consider naming a reputable animal sanctuary or rescue agency to select appropriate adoptive homes.

How long can a trust last? A trust that provides for breeding of offspring of your cat and perpetuating the cattery name ad infinitum, to be financially supported by the trust, would probably be disfavored by the courts (though preferred by many breeders). State laws differ as to whether your trust can benefit only those of your cats that are alive when your trust takes effect, or only those you own when the trust is created, or whether the trust can endure for 21 years after your death (regardless of how many cats are alive at that time). Consult an attorney in your state to ensure your trust meets your state’s criteria.

Co-ownership and estate planning. If you co-own a cat or cats, talk with the co-owner(s) about your estate plans. Consider establishing a trust that you and the co-owner(s) fund to benefit your co-owned cat(s). This helps protect your assets: Not only may you be able to share legal fees, but if you establish a trust without regard for a co-owner’s rights, that co-owner may challenge the trust in court. Even if your trust prevails, legal fees from such a fight may deplete the trust.

When your cat dies. Your trust should include instructions for disbursing any assets that remain when your cats die or the trust ends. Do not leave these assets to the caretaker; that gives a disincentive to provide a long and lavish life for your cat(s). Rather, ensure your caretaker receives adequate money only while the cats are alive and well cared for. When the cat dies or the trust ends, leave the residual money to a loved one or charity.

This article by Lisa Curry, Esq., originally appeared in the June 2008 issue of the American Kennel Club AKC Gazette (with a focus on dogs) and has been modified for The Purring Post and reprinted with permission. It is only an overview and does not constitute legal advice, yet it might provide some insights into the kinds of issues to consider when planning for your cat’s future.  You should consult an attorney in your state that is knowledgeable about estate planning to establish your cat’s trust.

 Lisa Curry practices law in New Jersey and provides information at her web site, www.lawfordogs.com  She shows and raises West Highland White Terriers. 

Print Friendly

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


145,538 Spam Comments Blocked so far by Spam Free Wordpress

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>